Prior to the release of subgraphs, there was a single graph accessed
through `app.graph`. Now that there's multiple graphs, there's a lot of
code that needs to be reviewed and potentially updated depending on if
it cares about nearby nodes, all nodes, or something else requiring
specific attention.
This was done by simply changing the type of `app.graph` to unknown so
the typechecker will complain about every place it's currently used.
References were then updated to `app.rootGraph` if the previous usage
was correct, or actually rewritten.
By not getting rid of `app.graph`, this change already ensures that
there's no loss of functionality for custom nodes, but the prior typing
of `app.graph` can always be restored if future dissuasion of
`app.graph` usage creates issues.
┆Issue is synchronized with this [Notion
page](https://www.notion.so/PR-7399-Cleanup-app-graph-usage-2c76d73d365081178743dfdcf07f44d0)
by [Unito](https://www.unito.io)
Changes the client-side validation of whether a graph has missing nodes
to use a simpler check (is the node name in the node defs from
`/object_info`), rather than using the Comfy Node Registry API
(api.comfy.org). The Registry API is still needed to get full
metadata/info about missing nodes, but that can be deferred until the
user actually needs that info.
This also fixes an issue where a node you coded yourself locally which
is neither a core node nor a node in the registry would be considered
"missing."
┆Issue is synchronized with this [Notion
page](https://www.notion.so/PR-6965-fix-don-t-use-registry-when-only-checking-for-presence-of-missing-nodes-2b76d73d365081e7b8fbcb3f2a1c4502)
by [Unito](https://www.unito.io)
Summary
- Add comprehensive telemetry for key UI interactions using existing
telemetry hooks (cloud-enabled, no-op in OSS):
Sidebar and top-level
- Node library button: `node_library`
- Model library button: `model_library`
- Workflows button: `workflows`
- Assets/Media button: `assets`
- Templates button: `templates`
- Keyboard Shortcuts: `keyboard_shortcuts`
- Console: `console`
- Help Center: `help_center`
- Settings (from Comfy logo menu): `settings_menu`
Floating canvas menu
- Minimap toggle: `minimap_toggle`
- Hide links toggle: `hide_links`
Run button and queue
- Run button handle (drag): `run_button_handle`
- Run mode selection: `run_instant`, `run_on_change`
- Queue multiple: `queue_multiple` fires on each run when batch count >
1 (moved from batch-count-change to run-time, per guidance)
Error dialogs
- Close (X/mask/ESC): `error_dialog_close` via dialog onClose
- Show report: `error_show_report`
- Help fix this: `error_help_fix_this`
- Find issues: `error_find_issues`
Nodes / Subgraphs
- Selection toolbox “Node info”: `node_info`
- Enter subgraph (node header enter): `open_subgraph`
- Subgraph breadcrumb navigation: `subgraph_breadcrumb_item` and
`subgraph_breadcrumb_root`
Settings / Credits / Search
- Settings menu button (under Comfy logo): `settings_menu`
- Purchase credits (Settings > Credits panel): tracked via existing
`trackAddApiCreditButtonClicked`
- Purchase credits (Avatar popover Top Up): tracked via existing
`trackAddApiCreditButtonClicked`
- Debounced search telemetry already present for node search and
template filters; left as-is
Notes and answers
- Error dialog onClose: only fires when the dialog actually closes (X,
mask, ESC, or programmatic close). “Show report” and “Help fix this” do
not close the dialog; they each emit their own events.
- Telemetry is behind the cloud provider; calls are optional
(`useTelemetry()?.…`). OSS builds send nothing.
Open questions / follow-ups
- Primary Run button click: today cloud-only `trackRunButton` exists; we
can also emit a UI-level `run` click (`UI_BUTTON_CLICKED` style)
alongside it if desired. Confirm preference and I can add it.
- Subgraph usage richness: if we want structured analytics (e.g.,
action, depth, subgraph id, node count), I can add a dedicated provider
method and include richer metadata at enter/breadcrumb.
- Optional parity: track the Comfy menu’s “Browse Templates” item in
addition to the sidebar Templates button.
Quality
- Ran `pnpm lint:fix` and `pnpm typecheck`; both pass locally.
Implementation details
- All handlers refactored to named functions where needed; used `void`
for intentionally unawaited async calls per lint rules.
- Event names kept consistent in `button_id` strings; happy to align to
a different naming scheme if you prefer.
┆Issue is synchronized with this [Notion
page](https://www.notion.so/PR-6511-feat-telemetry-add-tracking-for-sidebar-run-menu-dialogs-subgraphs-settings-and-cre-29e6d73d365081a1b8b4fdfbbf40e18b)
by [Unito](https://www.unito.io)
---------
Co-authored-by: Christian Byrne <cbyrne@comfy.org>
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
When renaming a workflow through the breadcrumb bar. It is intended to
complete the rename operation if the user clicks away from the text
input. However, completing the text input by pressing enter can cause
the rename operation to occur twice: On pressing enter and on loss of
focus. When this occurs, the second rename causes, an error to be raised
because renaming a workflow to the same name is not allowed.
Worse, a user should be able to cancel a rename by pressing escape, but
this still causes the "loss of focus" event to fire and rename the
workflow anyways.
As a simple fix to both of these, this PR disables rename on loss of
focus. A rename only occurs when the user completes a rename operation
with the enter key.
Resolves#6051
┆Issue is synchronized with this [Notion
page](https://www.notion.so/PR-6052-Skip-rename-operation-on-focus-lost-28c6d73d3650815d9a5fecd8567d4299)
by [Unito](https://www.unito.io)
## Summary
Enhancing and further modernizing the UI, giving users more usable area
whilst keeping farmiliar positioning and feel of elements.
## Changes
- **What**: Significant restructure of the UI elements, changing
elements from large blocks to floating elements, updating:
- Side toolbar menu (floating style, supports small/normal mode,
combines to scroll on height overflow)
- Bottom tabs panel (floating style, tabs redesigned)
- Action bar (support for docking/undocking menu)
- Added login/user menu button to top right
- Restyled breadcrumbs (still collapse when overflows)
- Add litegraph support for fps info position (so it isn't covered by
the sidebar)
- **Breaking**:
- Removed various elements and added new ones, I have tested custom
sidebars, custom actions, etc but if scripts are inserting elements into
"other" elements they may have been (re)moved.
- Remove support for bottom menu
- Remove support for 2nd-row tabs
## Screenshots
<img width="1116" height="907" alt="ui"
src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/b040a215-67d3-4c88-8c4d-f402a16a34f6"
/>
https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/571dbda5-01ec-47e8-b235-ee1b88c93dd0
┆Issue is synchronized with this [Notion
page](https://www.notion.so/PR-5980-Floating-Menus-UI-rework-2866d73d3650810aac60cc1afe979b60)
by [Unito](https://www.unito.io)
---------
Co-authored-by: GitHub Action <action@github.com>
Co-authored-by: github-actions <github-actions@github.com>
* [refactor] move workflow domain to its own folder
* [refactor] Fix workflow platform architecture organization
- Move workflow rendering functionality to renderer/thumbnail domain
- Rename ui folder to management for better semantic clarity
- Update all import paths to reflect proper domain boundaries
- Fix test imports to use new structure
Architecture improvements:
- rendering → renderer/thumbnail (belongs with other rendering logic)
- ui → management (better name for state management and UI integration)
This ensures proper separation of concerns and domain boundaries.
🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* [fix] Resolve circular dependency between nodeDefStore and subgraphStore
* [fix] Update browser test imports to use new workflow platform paths
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* [refactor] Improve renderer architecture organization
Building on PR #5388, this refines the renderer domain structure:
**Key improvements:**
- Group all transform utilities in `transform/` subdirectory for better cohesion
- Move canvas state to dedicated `renderer/core/canvas/` domain
- Consolidate coordinate system logic (TransformPane, useTransformState, sync utilities)
**File organization:**
- `renderer/core/canvas/canvasStore.ts` (was `stores/graphStore.ts`)
- `renderer/core/layout/transform/` contains all coordinate system utilities
- Transform sync utilities co-located with core transform logic
This creates clearer domain boundaries and groups related functionality
while building on the foundation established in PR #5388.
🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* fix: Clean up linter-modified files
* Fix import paths and clean up unused imports after rebase
- Update all remaining @/stores/graphStore references to @/renderer/core/canvas/canvasStore
- Remove unused imports from selection toolbox components
- All tests pass, only reka-ui upstream issue remains in typecheck
🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code)
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
* [auto-fix] Apply ESLint and Prettier fixes
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: GitHub Action <action@github.com>
* Implement subgraph publishing
* Add missing null check
* Fix subgraph blueprint display in workflows tab
* Fix demotion of subgraph blueprints on reload
* Update locales [skip ci]
* Update blueprint def on save, cleanup
* Fix skipped tracking on subgraph publish
When a subgraph is first published, it previously was not added to the
subgraphCache. This would cause deletion to fail until a reload occurred.
* Fix failing vite tests
A couple of tests that were mocking classes broke SubgraphBlueprint
inheritance. Since they aren't testing anythign related to subgraph
blueprints, the subgraph store is mocked as well.
* Make blueprint breadcrumb badge clickable
* Add confirmation for overwrite on publish
* Simplify blueprint badge naming
* Swap to promise.allSettled when fetching subgraphs
* Navigate into subgraph on blueprint edit
* Revert mission of value in blueprint breadcrumb
This was causing the blueprint badge to always display
* Misc code quality fixes
* Set subgraphNode title on blueprint add.
When a subgraph blueprint is added to the graph, the title of the
subgraphNode is now set to be the title of the blueprint.
NOTE: The name of the subgraph node when a blueprint is edited is left
unchanged. This may cause minor user confusion.
* Add "Delete Blueprint" option to breadcrumb
When editing a blueprint, the options provided for the root graph of the
breadcrumb included a Delete Workflow option. This still functioned for
deleting the current blueprint when selected, but didn't make sense. It
has been updated to instead describe that it deletes the current
blueprint
* Extract subgraph load code as function
* Fix subgraphs appearing in library after refresh
Subgraph nodes were hidden from the node library and context menu by
setting skip_list to true. Unfortunately, this causes them to be
mistakenly be caught and registered as vue nodes when a refresh is
performed. This is fixed by adding a check for skip_list.
* Add delete button and confirmation for deletion
* Use more specific warning for blueprint deletion
* At success toast on subgraph publish
Will return later to potentially add a node library link to the toast
* Don't apply subgraph context menu to normal nodes
Subgraph blueprints have a right click -> delete option in the node
library. This was incorrectly being dislplayed on non blueprint nodes.
* Remove hardcoded subgraphs path
Rather happy with this change. Rather than trying to introduce a
recursive import to pass a magic string, this solution is both
sufficient AND allows potential future extensions with less breakage.
* Fix nodeDef update on save
Wait to update the node def cache until after a blueprint has been
saved. Before, changes to links weren't actually being made visisble.
* Fix SaveAs with subgraph blueprints
* Remove ugly serialize/deserialize
Thought I had already tested this, and found that the mere existence of
proxies was causing issues, but simply adding a correct annotation is
sufficient now.
* Improve error specificity
* Framework for user defined blueprint descriptions
BlueprintDescription can be added to a workflows extra field to provide
more useful information about a blueprint's purpose
Actually hooking this up in a way that is user accessible is out of
scope for right now, but this will simplify future implementation.
* Cleanup breadcrumb dropdown options
Removes Dupliate for blueprints, adds a publish subgraph option.
The publish subgraph button currently routes through the save as logic.
Unforunately, this results in the prompt for name referencing workflows.
The cleanest way to resolve this is still being considered
* Move blueprint renaming into blueprint load
Blueprints should automatically set the name of the added node to the
filename when added. This mostly worked, but created uglier edgecases:
The subgraph itself wasn't renamed, and it would need to be
reimplemented to apply when editing a blueprint.
Instead, this is now applied when a subgraphBlueprint is first loaded.
This keeps all the logic routed through a single point
* Move saveAs prompt into workflow class
Ensures that the correct publish text is displayed when editing
blueprints without making an awful mess of imports
* Fix tests by making subgraphBlueprint internal
This has the added benefit of forcing better organization.
Reverts the useWorkflowThumbnail patch as it is no longer required.
* Add tests for subgraph blueprints
* Rewrite confirmation dialog
* Fix overwrite on publish new subgraph
1 is used as a placeholder size as -1 indicates the baking userFile is
temporary, not persisted, and therefore, not able to overwrite when
saved.
* When editing blueprint, tint background blue
* Fix blueprint tint at low LOD
* Set node source for blueprints to Blueprint
* Fix publish test
Making subgraph blueprints non temporary on publish made it so the
following load actually occurs. A mock has been added for this load.
* Fix multiple nits
* Further cleanup: error handling, and comments
* Fixing failing test cases
This also moves the bg tinting to a property of the workflow,
which makes things more extensible in the future.
* Fix temporary marking on publish.
The prior fix to allow overwrite of an existing blueprint on publish was
misguided. By marking a not-yet-loaded file as non-temporary, the load
performed prior to saving was actually fetching the file off disk and
discarding the existing changes. This additionally entirely prevented
publishing when a blueprint did not already exist with the current name.
To fix this, the blueprint is not marked as non-temporary until after
the load occurs. Note that this load is still required as it initializes
the change tracker state required for saving.
* Block unloading subgraph blueprints
Will need to be revisited if lazy loading is implemented, but this
requires solving some ugly sync/async issues.
---------
Co-authored-by: github-actions <github-actions@github.com>
* temp: move tailwind calls out of the layer
* temp: ts tailwind config
* upgrade: Tailwind v4
This got a little out of hand.
Had to add a relative reference to the stylesheet in any component that uses @apply instead of the utility classes directly.
* upgrade: bg-opacity is now a modifier
* fix: Classic menu buttons assume a border
* Update test expectations [skip ci]
* fix: New preflight removal pattern
* fix: Skeletons don't have skin
* Update test expectations [skip ci]
* fix: Missing @reference
* [auto-fix] Apply ESLint and Prettier fixes
---------
Co-authored-by: github-actions <github-actions@github.com>
Co-authored-by: GitHub Action <action@github.com>
