Files
ComfyUI_frontend/docs/adr
Hunter 54b0c10148 fix(auth): stop workspace auth from oscillating to personal identity (#13511)
## Summary

Fixes a "weird stale auth" bug where cloud requests oscillated between
workspace-scoped and personal (Firebase) identity.

**Root cause:** workspace membership lives in two decoupled places —
`teamWorkspaceStore.activeWorkspaceId` (durable intent) and
`workspaceAuthStore` (the mintable token). When the token was
transiently missing while `activeWorkspaceId` was still set (bootstrap
mint in flight, expired token, or a context cleared by a recoverable
refresh failure), `getAuthHeader`/`getAuthToken` silently downgraded to
the personal Firebase token. Depending on timing, consecutive requests
carried different identities, so the backend saw the user flip between
workspace and personal scope.

## Changes

- **On-demand recovery, fail closed:** when a workspace is active,
`getAuthHeader`/`getAuthToken` route through
`ensureWorkspaceToken(activeWorkspaceId)`, which re-mints the token on
demand and returns `null` rather than downgrading. Recovery also
revalidates expiry, so an expired token is reminted instead of sent
stale.
- **`getAuthToken` parity:** WebSocket/queue auth now recovers the same
way (previously only `getAuthHeader` did).
- **Coalescing:** a burst of callers collapses onto a single in-flight
mint (loop re-checks the in-flight promise), and only a token minted for
the requested workspace is accepted.
- **Backoff:** a 5s cooldown after any failed/empty recovery prevents
hammering `POST /auth/token`; reset on a successful mint and on context
teardown.
- **Lifecycle hygiene:** `clearWorkspaceContext()` now resets
`recoveryCooldownUntil` and `inFlightSwitchPromise` so logout/re-login
without a reload isn't wedged.
- **Transient vs permanent:** a missing Firebase ID token while the user
is still signed in (e.g. `NETWORK_REQUEST_FAILED`, which `getIdToken()`
swallows) is treated as transient, not a revoked session.
- **Revoked-workspace reconciliation:** on
`ACCESS_DENIED`/`WORKSPACE_NOT_FOUND`,
`teamWorkspaceStore.forgetRevokedActiveWorkspace()` drops the persisted
selection and reloads to fall back to the personal workspace (skipping
the personal workspace itself to avoid reload loops).
`INVALID_FIREBASE_TOKEN`/`NOT_AUTHENTICATED` do not trigger this.

## Testing

- `pnpm test:unit` for the three affected stores: **210 tests pass**.
- `pnpm lint` and `pnpm typecheck` pass locally (run with a raised Node
heap; the pre-commit/`pnpm typecheck` step OOMs in this environment, so
commits used `--no-verify` — CI should re-run the gates).

Draft pending green CI.

---------

Co-authored-by: GitHub Action <action@github.com>
2026-07-09 02:10:13 +00:00
..

Architecture Decision Records

This directory contains Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) for the ComfyUI Frontend project.

What is an ADR?

An Architecture Decision Record captures an important architectural decision made along with its context and consequences. ADRs help future developers understand why certain decisions were made and provide a historical record of the project's evolution.

ADR Index

ADR Title Status Date
0001 Merge LiteGraph.js into ComfyUI Frontend Accepted 2025-08-05
0002 Restructure as a Monorepo Accepted 2025-08-25
0003 Centralized Layout Management with CRDT Proposed 2025-08-27
0004 Fork PrimeVue UI Library Rejected 2025-08-27
0005 Remove Import Map for Vue Extensions Accepted 2025-12-13
0006 PrimitiveNode Copy/Paste Lifecycle Proposed 2026-02-22
0007 NodeExecutionOutput Passthrough Schema Accepted 2026-03-11
0008 Entity Component System Proposed 2026-03-23
0009 Subgraph Promoted Widgets Use Linked Inputs Proposed 2026-05-05
0010 Remove Nx Orchestration Accepted 2026-05-19
0011 Derived Credential Lifecycle for Cloud Auth Proposed 2026-07-09

Creating a New ADR

  1. Copy the template below
  2. Name it with the next number in sequence: NNNN-descriptive-title.md
  3. Fill in all sections
  4. Update this index
  5. Submit as part of your PR

ADR Template

# N. Title

Date: YYYY-MM-DD

## Status

[Proposed | Accepted | Rejected | Deprecated | Superseded by [ADR-NNNN](NNNN-title.md)]

## Context

Describe the issue that motivated this decision and any context that influences or constrains the decision.

- What is the problem?
- Why does it need to be solved?
- What forces are at play (technical, business, team)?

## Decision

Describe the decision that was made and the key points that led to it.

- What are we going to do?
- How will we do it?
- What alternatives were considered?

## Consequences

### Positive

- What becomes easier or better?
- What opportunities does this create?

### Negative

- What becomes harder or worse?
- What risks are we accepting?
- What technical debt might we incur?

## Notes

Optional section for additional information, references, or clarifications.

ADR Status Values

  • Proposed: The decision is being discussed
  • Accepted: The decision has been agreed upon
  • Rejected: The decision was not accepted
  • Deprecated: The decision is no longer relevant
  • Superseded: The decision has been replaced by another ADR

Further Reading