Files
ComfyUI_frontend/.claude/skills/bug-dump-ingest/reference/linear-api.md
Dante 559922eaa5 feat: add bug-dump-ingest skill (#11460)
## Summary

Adds a new Claude Code skill at `.claude/skills/bug-dump-ingest/` that
syncs the `#bug-dump` Slack channel into Linear as the system of record,
per discussion in [this
thread](https://comfy-organization.slack.com/archives/C075ANWQ8KS/p1776510375473579).

- Primary mode is bulk sync — every ingestable top-level message becomes
a Linear issue in the Frontend Engineering team's Triage state with
labels for area / env / severity / reporter.
- Marks handled messages via the team emoji scheme:
  - `` — ticket created
  - `:pr-open:` — fix PR open
  - `` — needs more context
  - `🔁` — duplicate
- Since the Slack reactions API isn't exposed to the skill, the
machine-readable marker is a thread reply carrying the Linear URL; the
human is prompted to add the visible parent reaction from a batch list
printed at session end.
- Secondary opt-in per-row mode delegates to `red-green-fix` to author a
failing unit + e2e test, then a minimal fix, then a PR.

## Files

- `SKILL.md` — entry point: workflow, classification, verification,
approval flow, Linear integration (MCP / GraphQL / draft fallback), fix
workflow
- `reference/linear-api.md` — GraphQL snippets for teams / states /
labels / issues
- `reference/schema.md` — field-by-field extraction rules
- `reference/examples.md` — seven worked examples from real recent
`#bug-dump` messages
- `reference/verify-commands.md` — cookbook of false-defect verification
commands

## Linear MCP setup

Two supported paths documented in `SKILL.md`:

- Option A: official hosted Linear MCP at `https://mcp.linear.app/sse`
via `claude mcp add`, OAuth-based, no API key.
- Option B: community self-hosted MCP with `LINEAR_API_KEY` in env.

## Test plan

- [ ] Restart Claude Code session after merging so the Linear MCP tools
register
- [ ] Authorize Linear OAuth on first tool call
- [ ] Dry-run the skill against a 48h window of `#bug-dump`, confirm the
approval table renders with all 9 columns
- [ ] File one real ticket end-to-end; verify labels, Triage state,
Slack thread reply, and permalink attachment
- [ ] Add a `` reaction on that parent; re-run and
confirm the message is skipped

┆Issue is synchronized with this [Notion
page](https://www.notion.so/PR-11460-feat-add-bug-dump-ingest-skill-3486d73d3650810094aee3e4ee79eb86)
by [Unito](https://www.unito.io)

---------

Co-authored-by: GitHub Action <action@github.com>
Co-authored-by: bymyself <cbyrne@comfy.org>
2026-04-24 07:20:35 +09:00

161 lines
9.0 KiB
Markdown

# Linear Slack Bot (@Linear) Reference
The skill drives Linear exclusively through the Linear Slack app (`@Linear`). **There is no Linear MCP, no `LINEAR_API_KEY`, no GraphQL.** Every Linear read/write happens as a Slack message that mentions `@Linear` in the `#bug-dump` thread, and the Linear Slack app performs the action and posts a reply card containing the issue URL.
## Why Slack-only
- The `#bug-dump` thread is already the source of truth; keeping the entire lifecycle (report → ticket → PR → resolution) in one thread means Processed Detection can grep the thread instead of a separate registry.
- No API key rotation, no MCP server install, no OAuth browser flow — works on any machine that already has the Slack MCP configured.
- The Linear Slack app's reply card (with issue URL, title, status, and assignee) IS the canonical receipt; the skill records its `ts` in the session log.
## Prerequisites (one-time, per workspace)
The Comfy Slack workspace must already have the Linear Slack app installed (it is — that's how humans use `@Linear` reactions today) and `#bug-dump` (channel `C0A4XMHANP3`) must have Linear enabled for the `Frontend Engineering` team. Nothing else to configure. If a `@Linear` invocation silently does nothing, the bot isn't present in the channel — surface that to the human rather than re-trying.
## Supported operations
Every operation is a `mcp__plugin_slack_slack__slack_send_message` call with `channel_id=C0A4XMHANP3` and `thread_ts=<parent-ts>`. The `text` is a natural-language instruction to the Linear bot. Keep the text concise — Linear parses the first line as the command intent.
### 1. Create an issue from the thread
```text
mcp__plugin_slack_slack__slack_send_message({
channel_id: "C0A4XMHANP3",
thread_ts: "<parent-ts>",
text: "@Linear create\nTeam: Frontend Engineering\nTitle: <title>\nStatus: Triage\nLabels: source:bug-dump, area:<area>, env:<env>, sev:<severity>, reporter:<handle>\n\n<description body>\n\nSource: <slack-permalink>"
})
```
Rules:
- Start with `@Linear create` on its own line — this is the command token the bot keys on.
- Always specify `Team: Frontend Engineering`. Without it, the bot falls back to the Slack workspace's default team, which may not be FE.
- `Status: Triage` pins the initial workflow state.
- `Labels:` — comma-separated. If a label doesn't exist yet in Linear, the bot creates it on first use (verified in Linear workspace settings). Keep the taxonomy exactly as SKILL.md § Label Taxonomy.
- `<description body>` — markdown per `reference/schema.md` Description Template. Use real newlines, not literal `\n`.
- End with `Source: <slack-permalink>` so the Linear issue body links back even if the auto-attachment of the parent message fails.
The Linear bot replies in the same thread with a card that contains:
- The Linear URL (`https://linear.app/comfy-org/issue/FE-NNNN`)
- Status, assignee (initially unassigned), and applied labels
- A "View in Linear" button
Parse the URL out of the bot's reply text (or attachments). If no card reply appears within ~10s of polling `slack_read_thread`, treat it as a creation failure — do NOT proceed to the `:white_check_mark:` confirmation reply.
### 2. Search existing open issues (dedupe)
```text
mcp__plugin_slack_slack__slack_send_message({
channel_id: "C0A4XMHANP3",
thread_ts: "<parent-ts>",
text: "@Linear search <keyword-1> <keyword-2>\nTeam: Frontend Engineering\nStatus: open"
})
```
The bot replies with a card listing up to ~5 matching open issues. Parse identifier (`FE-NNNN`) and URL per row. Treat a hit as a duplicate per SKILL.md § Pre-flight Dedupe Gate § Check 1.
If `@Linear search` is not supported in the installed Slack app version, fall back to Slack-native search across the `#bug-dump` thread replies (previous `@Linear` cards contain title + URL — grep those for the same keywords). Record which path was used in the session log so the human can see dedupe coverage.
### 3. Link an existing issue (dedupe: `L` response)
```text
mcp__plugin_slack_slack__slack_send_message({
channel_id: "C0A4XMHANP3",
thread_ts: "<parent-ts>",
text: "@Linear link FE-4521"
})
```
The bot replies with the linked issue card. The skill then posts its own `:white_check_mark: Linked to Linear: <URL>` confirmation reply (see SKILL.md § Slack Thread Reply).
### 4. Add labels to an existing issue
```text
mcp__plugin_slack_slack__slack_send_message({
channel_id: "C0A4XMHANP3",
thread_ts: "<parent-ts>",
text: "@Linear FE-4521 add-labels pr-open"
})
```
Used when an open PR is discovered after ticket creation and the Linear issue should flip to `pr-open`.
### 5. Change status
```text
mcp__plugin_slack_slack__slack_send_message({
channel_id: "C0A4XMHANP3",
thread_ts: "<parent-ts>",
text: "@Linear FE-4521 status In Progress"
})
```
Rarely used by the skill directly — usually status changes come from the `red-green-fix` PR lifecycle (Linear auto-moves to `In Review` when a PR references `Fixes FE-4521`).
## Description body template
The text that follows the command headers is rendered verbatim as the Linear issue description (markdown). Use this template — see `reference/schema.md` for field-by-field extraction notes:
```markdown
**Reporter:** <slack-display-name>
**Env:** cloud prod / local / electron / ...
**Severity (proposed):** high/medium/low
**Area:** ui / node-system / workflow / cloud / templates
## Repro
1. ...
2. ...
## Expected
...
## Actual
...
## Attachments (in Slack thread)
- image.png (png, 315 KB)
- Screen Recording.mov (mov, 37 MB)
## Source
Slack: <permalink>
Thread summary: <1-3 bullets if thread adds context>
```
The Slack permalink is load-bearing — it's the canonical route to attachments, reporter, and any follow-up discussion. Do NOT embed Slack file IDs (`F0AT...`) directly; they're permissioned.
## Parsing the bot's reply
After each `slack_send_message` that mentions `@Linear`, poll `slack_read_thread` (with `channel_id=C0A4XMHANP3`, `thread_ts=<parent-ts>`) up to 3 times, ~3s apart. Scan replies authored by the Linear Slack app user for:
- Any `https://linear.app/<org>/issue/FE-\d+` URL → capture as the issue URL.
- The `FE-NNNN` identifier pattern → capture as the issue identifier.
- An error phrase (`couldn't`, `failed`, `not found`, `no team matched`) → treat as failure; surface the full bot text to the human.
Record the bot reply's `ts` alongside the captured URL and identifier in the session log.
## Failure modes & handling
| Symptom | Likely cause | Handling |
| ------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| No bot reply within 10s | Linear app not in channel, or bot outage | Halt the batch, surface to human, do NOT fabricate a Linear URL. Remaining approved candidates stay queued for re-run. |
| Bot replies with "no team matched" | Team name typo or Linear workspace drift | Re-send with the exact team name from the Linear workspace (default: `Frontend Engineering`). If it still fails, ask the human to verify. |
| Bot replies with "couldn't parse labels" | One of the labels has syntax the bot rejects | Drop the offending label, re-send; log the partial-label failure so the human can patch after. |
| Bot creates the issue but reply lacks the URL | Rare bot format change | Re-fetch the thread after ~5s; if URL still absent, open Linear search via `@Linear search <title>` and recover the identifier + URL. |
| Multiple `@Linear` replies match (duplicate card) | The skill retried without polling first | Keep the earliest card's URL; log the extras. Never re-issue `@Linear create` for the same candidate without confirming the first card failed. |
Never retry `@Linear create` without first running `@Linear search` for the same title keywords — a duplicate card is worse than an initial failure because the human has to close one of them manually.
## Why no direct API path
- The Linear MCP (official or community) would require either OAuth setup or `LINEAR_API_KEY` in env — both are per-machine hurdles the skill should not depend on.
- Direct GraphQL against `api.linear.app` has the same key-management cost and bypasses the Slack thread as the audit trail.
- Routing every action through `@Linear` in the thread gives humans full visibility in the channel (the bot's card is the receipt) and Processed Detection becomes a simple Slack thread read.
If a future need requires capabilities the `@Linear` Slack app doesn't expose (bulk operations, private field edits, webhooks), stop and surface the limitation to the human rather than quietly adding an API-key path — the "Slack-only" constraint is intentional.